[FFML] [fanfic][Yotsuba&!][oneshot] Fuuka & Home

Mythril Moth mythrilmoth at sbcglobal.net
Fri Sep 16 07:51:55 PDT 2011


>> My comment on this story is that maybe it takes characters away from 
>> where
>> they started.  When was the last time that happened in fanfiction?
>
> All the time.

Which is kind the point of fanfiction in the first place.

The wonderful thing about fanfiction is that it's a wide open sandbox. We're 
not here to create carbon copies of what already exists. We're here to 
explore the avenues of possibility a work has to offer. How far a writer 
strays from the original tone of a series is a matter of preference, whether 
it's a tongue-in-cheek parody of the original (such as Andrew Huang's 
Evanjellydonut) or stories that do in fact mesh precisely with the tone and 
style of the original, or stories that go somewhere dangerous and disturbing 
(The Bitter End, anyone?). For most writers, fanfiction is about doing 
something different, and the challenge is to make it compelling, even if 
(ESPECIALLY if) it takes on a tone completely unlike the source material.

If the reader doesn't particularly like where the writer goes with the 
story, then there's a simple solution: Stop reading it. Anything beyond that 
is entirely unnecessary and uncallled for.


==================
Mythril Moth
www.mythrilmoth.net




More information about the ffml mailing list