Subject: [FFML] Re: that hp/ranma thing
From: croaker@rochester.rr.com
Date: 6/29/2004, 11:02 AM
To: thermopyle@tds.net
CC: ffml@anifics.com





"Amazon law does not allow the intermarriage between normal 
people 
and wizards. There are so few wizards, the laws were meant to 
help 
promote growth.?"

...I'm failing to see the logic behind this reasoning.  There 
isn't, as far as I know, a single case mentioned in the books 
where a muggle and a wizard had children who weren't magical.  
There is, however, the reverse; at least two cases, iirc about 
Tonks's father being a muggle.  Also, it is clear that muggles 
can 
have magical children.  So Cologne's statement would argue 
that 
the children of wizards and muggles tend to be non-magical, 
which 
just isn't supported.  At the very least, Cologne has to state 
directly that it IS the case, since there is not canon 
information 
that anywhere near suggests such.

And how many wizards in the Hogwarts world actually believe and 
understand that? I'd say... somewhat less than half. There's still 
a fairly strong level of anti-muggle sentiment, and belief that 
"purebloods" are better than "halfbloods". Cologne's shown herself 
to be strongly prejudiced about things in the past, it's no 
surprise to find her reacting in such a way again here.

Again, something that should be indicated in the fic.  Cologne's 
statement comes across as fact, and a fact that doesn't make 
sense, so it needs support either to make it believable or to make 
it clear to the reader that she's talking out her wrinkled ass.


Probably something yet to come. We don't need to have everything explained to us in chapter one, if we did, what would the point be to having the rest of the story?

Also, I'm interested in how the whole English thing is going to be 
handled.  A translation spell seems unlikely, unless it's passive 
and doesn't actually involve Ranma being taught the language.  A 
passive spell such as that could be interesting, if students 
(Malfoy?) started figuring out how to turn it off.  An active, 
learning spell doesn't work, because then you have to ask why it 
can't be used for things other than languages.  That Ranma already 
knows English is fairly unbelievable, as well...

A passive spell on Ranma would make the most sense, I think.  ^_^

Ranma's level of knowledge of English tends to vary with the author as you traverse through fanon. I personally find it entirely reasonable, given his continuous travels, that he'd have spent long enough in English-speaking regions to pick up the language.

One of my favorite explanations for why he finds class so boring is that he's already fluent in English, so why should he have to be in that class in the first place? ;)



-- "This is the price of freedom: Your last pint of blood, ounce of pain, drop of courage. Paid in advance." .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List----. | Administrators - ffml-admins@anifics.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@anifics.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---- http://ffml.anifics.com/faq.txt -----'