Subject: [FFML] Re: [C&C][Xover][Ranma][Ah! My Goddess!] Young At Heart
From: "Thermopyle" <Thermopyle@tds.net>
Date: 5/24/2002, 7:34 AM
To: "Chan Wei Lik" <weimin@pl.jaring.my>, <ffml@anifics.com>


----- Original Message -----
From: "Chan Wei Lik" <weimin@pl.jaring.my>
To: <ffml@anifics.com>
Sent: Friday, May 24, 2002 3:32 AM
Subject: [FFML] Re: [C&C][Xover][Ranma][Ah! My Goddess!] Young At Heart



From: Thermopyle

This is just great! More AMG fics than I usually see in a whole month.

Heh.  I liked Megumi's Wish, haven't read the other one yet, though.  ^_^

This story takes place during the Mushroom of Aging arc in the Ranma
manga, and during the Trials of Morisato arc in the A!MS! manga.

I think it would be more accurate for you to say that this is an
_alternative_ to what took place in those stories.

No... It would only be accurate to say that if it happened after an
alternative version of those stories.  Since it diverges inside the stories,
however, it's true that it's happening during the stories.  ^_^;

"I... I'm sorry... Those were the last ones," Akane said, her soot-stained
face downcast.

She _does_ still have those last two hidden and will be trying to reach him,
right?

Yup.  ^_^;

No doubt about it, though, if she was older she would have been a fiancee.

That just sounds so... wrong...

I couldn't help putting it in.  It seemed so true.  :)

They might have been rivals but he still didn't want Ryouga to get killed
for his foolishness.

Quite a contrast to his earlier thoughts.

Not quite.  He would have revealed Ryouga's curse if Ryouga hadn't been made
younger.  The whole way this is approached is that Ryouga, in his child form,
is vulnerable and Akane could kill him on accident(which wouldn't really
happen, I don't think, but this IS Ranma's POV, and he's not happy with Akane
right now).  In his adult body, that wouldn't be a problem.

"Why don't you just make two more of them?" asked Skuld, who, she noted
with no small amount of annoyance, was still bigger than her.  At least
she was flat for her age, even if she was still bigger than Urd
currently was.  That was a small victory, at any rate.<<

You can make the paragraph less akward if you change it to something like
this:

"Why don't you just make two more of them?" asked Skuld, who, she noted
with no small amount of annoyance, was still bigger than her.  At least
she was flat for her age. That was a small victory, at any rate.

Eh... yeah, I think I'll change this.

She noticed Belldandy was standing on the table the other two were sitting
at, quietly watching them talk.

I saw that some readers weren't clued to the fact that Belldandy was shrunk.
All you have to do is change 'She noticed Belldandy was...' to 'She noticed
that the still-miniture Belldandy was...'

Yeah.  Probably, 'Belldandy, who was still shrunk, stood on the table...' or
whatever goes well into that sentance.  I'm not going to try to explain why
she's shrunk at that point, though.

she wondered where Belldandy had gotten clothes small enough to fit her
without raiding Skuld's closet.

Actually, Urd is younger than Skuld (who is now normal and no longer
slipping in age thanks to the moonrock) at this point. So much so that
Skuld's clothes couldn't fit her.

True.  I'll change this.

Eventually the exited and headed down one of the roads that ran alongside
it,

That should be 'she exited...' I think.

Yup.  Changed.

Despite the way the girl was having a bit of difficulty making her way up
it, she still had that annoying smile on her face,

Ranma is not in a position to see her smile.

Eh... I'll have to look at this.  I seem to recall that Urd isn't looking
around much, but I need to check.  If I didn't specifically say that, he could
have noticed the smile on her face as she looked to the sides.  I'll probably
just remove or fix this somehow, though.

feeling slightly guilty that he was about to walk around the house without
taking his own off first,

He could always put them in his pack.

He'd have to stop, put the pack down, take his shoes off, pick the pack back
up, then repeat when he goes to leave... unless he just left the pack
somewhere, I guess, which is a possibility.

"Skuld," she said, "it's time to eat."

After the other fic, I don't even want to comment on this matter.

Heh.  Yeah, I never noticed that they aren't seen to eat, so... ^_^;

You and Belldandy already used up the moon rock's power!

Skuld used it up. Belldandy get any.

Yup.  Just assumed that Belldandy got some, since she was with Skuld.  But
yeah, it was just Skuld, with some left over for Urd, instead.

Otherwise he wouldn't figure he could learn how to use my secondary power
source himself.

How about 'Otherwise he would figure out he couldn't...'?

Er... maybe.

True.  Forgot to mention it at some point beforehand.  Actually, there's
not
any more warning for that than there is for the Skuld being grown bit.

By this point, Skuld is back to her normal age.

Yup.  Been too long since I looked at this, had been thinking that Skuld, like
Urd, only has the process partially reversed.  ^_^;

I'll try to figure out how to fix the whole miniature Belldandy thing,
without just dropping a summary straight into the fic.  That might be
necessary, but I'd hate to have to do it.  It'd just
interrupt the flow of things too much for my tastes.  >_<

You never explained why Ranma is 5 years old either, assumning that the
reader knew what you were talking about. You can do that for the AMG part
too. If you get an opportunity in the story to explain things then do so.
Otherwise, it's not a priority.

Yup.  That's probably how I'll handle it.

This is such a sweet and WAFFy fic. I'd look forward to seeing more of it.

Er... it is?  Well, that's good, I suppose.  ^_^;

Anyway, thanks for the comments.  Hopefully it won't be too long a wait.  :)

Now... gottagotoworki'mrunninglatei'llrespondtotheotheremaillater,bye!  ^_^;


             .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List----.
             | Administrators - ffml-admins@anifics.com |
             | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@anifics.com |
             |     Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject     |
             `---- http://ffml.anifics.com/faq.txt -----'