Subject: [FFML] Re: [Fic][Ranma] Consequences
From: Bjorn Christianson
Date: 5/2/2002, 5:20 PM
To: dougmacd@dougmacd.net
CC: ffml@anifics.com

} Date: Wed, 01 May 2002 21:28:43 -0400
} From: Douglas MacDougall <dougmacd@dougmacd.net>

Here's some comments, for all that they're worth.

}     The metal bar does indeed miss the vase, instead hitting the table
} underneath it.  In fact, it hits the table surface precisely on-edge.
} The piece of wooden furniture slides back a handful of centimeters
} before being stopped by a wall.  And then the momentum of the rebar does
} its work.

"On-edge" sounds strange to me -- I'd normally expect either
"edge-on" or "on the edge."
 
}     I normally wouldn't use that sort of language, but...  Damn, it's
} not a splinter; it's a friggin' stake!  The thing's a decimeter long,
} and coated with my blood!

Maybe "ten centimetres" instead of "decimetre"?  Decimetres
are a very rarely used unit.
     
}     He continues to stare at me for a moment, before reaching into his
} jacket.  Is he going for his gun?  Oh no, he's gonna kill me!  I'm gonna
} die!!

Heh.  I really like the scared-but-trying feeling you've
given Hiroshi.
 
}     Spark, who's been dancing warily around the "boss," plucks something
} off of my collarbone.  I freak, tensing up and spinning towards him.
} What's he doing?!
} 
}     He must have completely misread my body language, since he's
} apologizing!  "Sorry, man!  Sorry!  But, but check this out!  Cool,
} huh?"  He holds up a limp bit of fabric or something between his hands.

This threw me off a bit, because the startling thing to me
is not that Spark is apologizing, but *why* he's apologizing
-- that is, to stop from offending Hiroshi, rather than just
saying, "Sorry I surprised you."  Maybe more of a
description of Spark's body language?
 
}     "Damn, you've got presence, man!  I heard about you Furinkan types,
} but I never believed it!  But shit, bam!  You just blew that thing up.
} Was that some sort of exploding ki, or something?  Dude!"

I like Spark. ;)
 
}     He glances back at me one last time before getting into the driver's
} seat; Spark is already in the passenger side.  "We'll see."  This time
} his smile shows teeth.  Earlier in the night it would have felt like a
} wolf baring it's fangs, but right now it almost seems friendly.

"baring its fangs"
 
}     "Tell me.  On that night, why didn't you pull out the blade of wood
} from your neck until you got outside?"

Maybe "shard" or "splinter" instead of "blade"?  To me,
"blade" implies something manufactured.
 
}     "But it only took one.  He saw something in your actions, or
} something in your eyes that put fear into heart.  Instead of trying to
} hold out in a show of power, he immediately capitulated.  It would have
} been the end result regardless, but you helped expedite things.

"fear into his heart"?
 
}     "I understand.  You don't want to be a yakuza for the rest of your
} life.  But I'm not looking for people satisfied to gangsters."

"satisfied to be gangsters"
 
Great story all round.  I especially liked your
characterization of Nabiki, which manages to be both
sympathetic without necessarily glossing over the rough
spots of her actions.  It's also a very nice semi-sequel to
"A Tale of Ten Yen," and as D.F. and Gary have both
mentioned, stands very well on its own rights.

Bjorn

-- bjorn@etho.caltech.edu http://www.its.caltech.edu/~bjorn Computation & Neural Systems, Caltech 216-76, Pasadena CA 91125 .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List----. | Administrators - ffml-admins@anifics.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@anifics.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---- http://ffml.anifics.com/faq.txt -----'