Subject: [FFML] Re: [Ranma/Tenchi] Process of Elimination -- Chapter Four
From: Bjorn Christianson
Date: 9/19/2001, 1:34 AM
To: brian@azurite.org
CC: ffml@anifics.com

} Date: Sat, 01 Sep 2001 10:54:12 -0700
} From: Brian Randall <brian@azurite.org>

}     Er... yeah. Sorry about the delay. ^_^;;;

This C&C is not late.  You are imagining things.  This C&C
is completely prompt, and when I promised it.  Upon
receiving this C&C, you will send me fifty dollars.

}     Blinking, her arm protectively encircling the child sleeping at her 
} side, Washuu eyed the newcomer in surprise. Suu stirred slightly, but 
} remained asleep. Ranma, however, was on his feet in a heartbeat, tensed 
} for battle, though he held his blades in reserve. "What do you want?" he 
} asked mistrustfully.

COLOGNE:  A cup of sugar.

I found the phrasing a bit awkward here.  My first
impression was that Suu was "the newcomer"; and then,
Ranma.  Of course, this is only a problem because the scene
is set up in the previous chapter, rather than here -- which
isn't a problem if you're reading this as a story, rather
than one chapter at a time.

}     The old woman before him cackled, shaking her head, "Calm yourself, 
} Muko-dono. I heard from the other boys what you did. I'm
} impressed." 

COLOGNE:  I was ten times your age before I mastered Dance
          Dance Revolution!

} She 
} looked upwards, sighing, and waved her staff towards the ships overhead. 
} "I've not seen anything like this in all my years. I haven't seen one of 
} the 'monsters' myself, either... but I hear that you've fought some of 
} them. Hmm... and the boys say that your father killed one..." she 
} trailed off, frowning darkly. "But that's not the point."

RANMA:  So were you gonna make one anytime soon?

This does strike me as a bit rambling for Cologne, in all
seriousness. 
 
}     He nodded again, not looking away from the small figure. "Yeah. She 
} taught me the soul of ice and the hiryuu-shouten-ha."

Normally, wouldn't that be "Soul of Ice" and "Hiryuu Shouten
Ha"?  (I'm not sure how you did it in the past chapters.)
 
}     "Hey!" Ranma protested, crossing his arms over his chest. "I beat 
} you before."
} 
}     She glanced at Ranma, and hid a small smile. "No. You beat my shark, 
} Ranma."

Heh.
 
}     He settled for glowering at the older woman, saying nothing. Washuu 
} raised an eyebrow. That was likely an interesting story... time for that 
} later, though. "Well, it's nice of you to offer to help, but we'd need a 
} whole _army_ to try and stave off the reavers."

"interesting story.  Time for" (Or use a semi-colon, or you
could leave it -- but it is an unnecessary ellipsis.)

}     Cologne chuckled dryly. "Ask, and ye shall receive."

SUU:  Oo!  Bananas?

}     Washuu blinked, her confusion rapidly growing. "What's in China?"

RANMA:  *Really* good ramen.

SUU:  Banana ramen?
 
}     Yosho eyed the beat-up and worn cars as they rolled into the street 
} ahead of him. The first was in fair condition, packed with a worried 
} looking family, and the other was an aging and failing pickup truck, 
} that sputtered and ground to a halt a short distance away.

Given that you go on to make a distinction between them, I'd
drop the "beat-up and worn".  (Especially as it clashes with
the description of the first car.)
 
}     Yosho's eyebrows shot up in surprise. "Bogard-san," he called out, 
} recognizing the tall man. "You came to Tokyo after all?"

BOGARD:  Isn't this Kyoto?

RYOGA:  That's *my* line, dammit!  Follow the script!
 
}     Terry nodded, his features still set with the seemingly dead look he 
} had worn before. 

I'd drop the "seemingly".  The reader knows what a "dead
look" is like, and all the modifier does is weaken the description.

}     Flicking the radio's volume down, the swordsman sighed, one hand 
} fiddling with the 'imitation' key that Washuu had given him. He didn't 
} really want to know how she had come up with it -- the woman was eerily 
} capable, and it worked much like the tenchi-ken. Asking to no more would 
} likely be asking for trouble. "So much for that. So what are you 
} planning next?"

Hum.  Again, I'd think that "Tenchi-ken" would be
capitalized, as it is a proper name.

"Asking to know more"
 
}     Terry frowned, watching the stopped car resume its pace, 
} accelerating down the still empty street.
"resume its pace" sounds odd to me, in this context.
Perhaps "lurch into motion", or similar?

}     Yosho rubbed at his chin thoughtfully, then shrugged, beckoning 
} Terry to follow. "Well, let's meet up with Ranma and Washuu, Bogard-san. 
} Perhaps we can discuss with them."

"discuss it" or "discuss that" or "discuss bananas."  You
need an object, anyways. :)

}     Tenchi stalked forward, Ryouko drifting at one side, and Ayeka 
} scurrying along the other, attended by the Guardians. Ryo-oh-ki sighed 
} tiredly from her position atop Kamidake, while Tenchi scanned the 
} largely deserted streets.

This is a really minor point, but it's not actuall clear who
the Guardians are attending to.

}     "He has to be around here," he muttered. "Those girls said that 
} Washuu came here with two men, and one of them was Ranma. Jiji must be 
} one of the others. Why is he calling himself Yosho, though?"

RYOKO:  Chicks.

AYEKA:  Chicks.

KAMIDAKE:  Guardians... I mean, chicks.
 
}     Ayeka coughed politely, offering, "Katsuhito is truly Yosho, 
} Tenchi-dono. He's my older brother, and the, ah, heir to the throne."

TENCHI:  And the guy you wanted to boink?

AYEKA:  That too.

}     Ayeka nodded, while Ryouko snickered, "Just like Ayeka." The 
} princess colored angrily, but said nothing at the insult.

I'd drop the "at the insult" -- a bit redundant.
 
}     "Tenchi?" he asked, seemingly surprised at the boy's presence.

Now, this is of course personal preference, but I don't like
the use of adjectives like "seemingly surprised."  It's a
bit of a cop-out.  Either Yosho *is* surprised, in which
case the effect is unnecessarily weakened; or you're trying
to convey that he looks surprised to Tenchi, in which case
you're copping out on delivering a proper description (even
something as simple as "blinking in startlement").

I'll shut up now.
 
}     "Yeah?" Tenchi managed, still horribly confused by the entire 
} ordeal. "Who are you?"

YOSHO:  I am your grandfather.  You killed Inigo Montoya.

}     Yosho looked uncomfortably, and hedged evasively, "I wanted to let 
} my descendants live a life away from the pressures of the court." He 
} shook his head suddenly, straightening. "What are you doing here, 
} Tenchi? You should be somewhere safe -- not here."
} 
}     Tenchi shook his head dismissively. "It's not important... I'm here 
} to find you."

If it's not important, why is he answering the question? ;)
 
}     Eyes narrowing, Yosho clasped his hands together behind his back. It 
} was a gesture Tenchi knew too well, one that made him wonder what his 
} 'grandfather' was planning. "And what are you going to do now that 
} you've found me?"

Yosho *is* his grandfather.  The quotes are... peculiar.
 
}     The boy's dismay increased, and he found himself struggling for 
} words, no longer sure what to say. Ayeka had no subtle advice this time, 
} and Ryouko seemed as much at a loss as he was. The guardians kept 
} respectfully silent, and Ryo-oh-ki would likely be no help anyway... 
} "So... you're just like the Emperor? You can help, but you refuse to?"

This seems a bit OOC for Tenchi to me.  He strikes me as
much more likely to shout out the real situation here,
rather than being bullied into submission.  A recurring
theme in the OAVs (and the manga which shares the
continuity) is how in times of stree, Tenchi's leader
qualities come forth.
 
}     Not even thinking about it, but surrendering to his rage, Tenchi 
} lashed out, shoving the taller man. "Stop being such an idiot! Lives are 
} at stake! Come _on_!"
} 
}     Yosho staggered back, seemingly shocked at Tenchi's lashing out. 
} "NO!" he roared, shoving Tenchi back. "I'll not speak of this further." 
} With that Yosho turned his back on Tenchi, leaving the boy to fume at 
} nothing.

"Lashing out" twice in short order.  It's not clear that
Tenchi physically lashed out.  See my notes on
"seemingly". ;)

And, again, this just seems very OOC.  Tenchi and Yosho have
both been always fairly level-headed, with a great deal of
respect for each other -- Tenchi is arguably closer to his
grandfather than his father.  This whole fight, coming as it
does basically from the refusal of either to listen or
explain, is a bit hard to swallow, even with the
circumstances. 
 
}     He sighed, rising slightly. "I don't know what I'm supposed to do 
} about it, but okay. Where are they?" He glanced down at Washuu, who was 
} watching him intently. "Um... Washuu...I'll be back in a bit. Tsunami 
} needs me to look at something."

WASHUU:  Ranma, you pervert!  *WHAM!*
 
}     He nodded in understanding, flashing her a quick grin before rising 
} into the air, guided by Tsunami's voice. "They are east of you, Ranma, 
} some distance, but you should be able to tell the place when you see it."

"recognize the place", perhaps?
 
}     The answer that came back was somewhat hesitant. "I... asked 
} Saryu-oh for help, and I know the way your jewels work."

... I don't think I can come up with a perverted comment to
top that, you know.
 
}     Ranma blinked at that, wondering if the normally stately woman had 
} said the words he had thought he heard. "Um," he said after a moment, 
} deciding it was merely wording, and nothing else, "you mean the stone in 
} my wrist?"

TSUNAMI:  Oh, my.  Masu anatomy is certainly very strange.

}     Flinching in surprise, he stepped back, narrowly deflecting her 
} punch. "Hey," he said, seemingly calm despite the situation, "is that 
} how it is? I don't want to hurt you."

BOGARD:  Love!  And Peace!
 
}     Snorting, he dodged past her next attack, a perfectly placed elbow 
} strike slamming into the back of her neck as she slipped past him, 
} sending her sprawling. Pulling herself to her feet, she eyed the man, 
} awaiting her in a loose, mobile stance, and spat out the dirt and gravel 
} from her awkward landing. "Your call. Terry the 'Lone Wolf' Bogard. Your 
} name?"

"Terry 'The Lone Wolf' Bogard"  (Unless his name is Terry
the Bogard, of course. ;)
 
}     The man edged back warily at the sight of the blade, seeming to take 
} a moment to focus himself. A lambent sheet of blue flame seemed to erupt 
} from somewhere within the man, cloaking him in its glowing aura. "No 
} more playing nice, eh?"

RYOKO:  Pewwwww-ee!  
 
}     Yosho raised his shield arm, deflecting a strike that would have 
} gotten through. "Hah," he snorted. "If you believe that, then you are a 
} fool, Tenchi! I thought you were raised more intelligently."

YOSHO:  I mean, I bought Dr. Spock and everything!
 
}     Another voice broke the pair's concentration. "No, but you should 
} listen to your mother, and she says you're being a spoiled brat." A 
} newcomer landed near Terry, eyeing Ryouko warily. "Bogard-san," he 
} remarked, only pausing to glance at the blond man, "it's been a while. 
} I'll stay here, can you help Yosho for me?"

"stay here.  Can you help"  (Need a new sentence.)
 
}     "Tsunami asked me to keep Yosho and Tenchi from killing each other." 
} He paused for a moment, glancing towards something over one shoulder 
} before admitting, "Well, not entirely. She had much prettier words. 
} Anyway. I'm not in the mood to let you go around blowing up half the 
} city and maybe some of our allies while you're at it."

RYOKO:  Oh yeah?

RANMA:  Yeah.  If you're not gonna get the whole city, 
        don't bother.

RYOKO:  Um.  Right.
 
}     He perched loosely atop a weather vane, looking down at the pitted 
} and ruined rooftop. "What the hell?" he muttered. "You can only break 
} things. You can only destroy." 

... This from Saotome "Mountain-smasher" Ranma?

}     The boy stared, seemingly shocked, and clenched his fists at his 
} side. "Eh?" His eyes dimmed, and he blinked. "I'm..." He shook his head. 
} "You're saying that I'm only a weapon, aren't you?"

RYOKO:  No.  You have a blender attachment, too.
 
}     Righting herself and rebounding off of the surface, she leapt 
} upwards, bearing her energy blade. "What?"

That exclamation makes no sense to me in context, I'm afraid.
 
}     Ryouko sank beneath the street, leaving Ranma to plow into it, 
} creating a meters-wide crater limed in sharpened fragments of frozen and 
} icy asphalt. "Oh-HO!" Ryouko exclaimed, reappearing above Ranma. "So who 
} are _you_?"

"crater lined in sharpened"  (typo)
 
}     Ranma snarled wordlessly, willing himself to shift back into his 
} proper form. There was a moist... tearing sensation from deep inside, as 
} the change took place, but he ignored it, reassuming the form he wanted. 
} "I'm the same damn person I've always been," he growled.

RANMA:  Well, except for the Neko-ken.  And the time I got
        hit on the head and became a girl.  And....
 
}     Tsunami wasn't certain when she had told Saryu-oh to send her to the 
} site, but she knew that she had arrived, and everyone on the street had 
} paused their senseless melee to look at her. She looked at both Tenchi 
} and Yosho sternly, crossing her arms over her chest. "What is the 
} meaning of this?" she asked.

TENCHI:  Well, in the Jungian philosophy, fighting is an
         external manifestation of....
 
}     Tenchi sheathed his blade, stepping back from Yosho, as the older 
} man did the same. Yosho spoke first. "Tsunami-sama, I'm sorry. Tenchi... 
} does not quite understand the situation that we are in here--"
} 
}     The boy overrode his grandfather. "Tsunami! Yosho is being an idiot--"

YOSHO:  Am not!  You're the stupid-head!

}     The two found themselves silenced by Ayeka. "You're _both_ being 
} idiots!"

Well, *this* I can agree with.

}     Tsunami blinked, turning to face her theoretical sibling. "Can you 
} tell me what is happening?"

"Theoretical sibling" doesn't sound right to me, but I'll be
damned if I could come up with a better term.
 
}     The scientist resisted the urge to laugh, half-afraid that the 
} carefully restrained hysteria would break loose. "I'm much older than I 
} look," she assured the Amazon. "I can go for a few days without sleep 
} just fine."

WASHUU:  At least, that's what the pixies tell me.  Could
         you pass me more of those pills, please?
 
}     Nodding slowly, the old woman stared at Washuu's screen. "That's an 
} interesting device... I'll trust you on this -- you feel like the type 
} that knows what you are doing. But what will this benefit us?"

WASHUU:  Think of the tourism!  Reaver-spotting tours!
         Postcards!  Little plushies!
 
}     His mind balked for a moment, a surge of pain and confusion denying 
} him the correct answer. "I'm..." he shook his head, staring at her 
} again. "I'm not givin' up. I'm not loosing. I don't... don't care. Gonna 
} beat you, then I'm gonna beat the reavers."

"I'm not losing."  (typo)
 
}     The darkness encroached further, the woman before him staring from a 
} pinpoint of light in a vast sea of black, as his hand fell away. A slow 
} rushing noise filled his ears, and he dimly heard his voice, slowly and 
} thickly, so different as to be someone else's... "Gotta protect... what 
} I... love..."

And ever after, his ghost haunted the restaurants of Nerima.
 
}     Ran-oh-ki winced, turning his head about and sniffing in worry. His 
} partner was in pain, and only getting worse.

"In" should be "a", I think. ;)
 
}     Tsunami stared into the distance, seemingly distracted by something, 
} while everyone else had simply lapsed into silence, ignoring everyone. 
} Perhaps waiting for him to make the next move, he thought.

You really need to make clear who "he" is.  Unless Tsunami's
changed genders, that is.
 
}     Yosho's eyes widened in shock. Tenchi, as Yosho had known him, was 
} strong of will, and not one to so casually back down from something he 
} had chosen to fight for. That the boy would simply throw away everything 
} -- his attack on Yosho, their argument, his position of superiority -- 
} was staggering. That he threw himself to the ground, and used the name 
} that he had... "Tenchi. Stop."

"Position of superiority"?  Since when?
 
}     It galled him, churning his stomach. Tenchi remained where he was, 
} speaking loudly enough to be heard from his awkward position. "This one 
} humbly begs an answer of you, Yosho-sama."

... I am suddenly reminded of the whips'n'chains nature of
Jurai romance.  This isn't about to go yaoi on me, is it?
 
}     Yosho blinked, trying to focus his thoughts from the frantic and 
} confused jumble that they had assumed with the knowledge of his 
} inevitable return to Jurai. He had spent hundreds of years on earth 
} avoiding that return. To no avail, now.

"years on Earth"  (should be capitalized)
 
}     Terry winced, perhaps something in Yosho's words resonating with 
} something in himself, or his own past. "I think I can understand that," 
} he said after a moment. "So you're gonna leave, but you don't want to?"

I'd suggest dropping the "or his own past" -- implied as is.
 
}     Yosho pursed his lips thoughtfully. "My Father wishes me to take the 
} throne, which I have long been trying to avoid."

"My father wishes me" (no capital.)
 
}     Then, too, she remembered the first incident clearly from the second 
} instance her hand had been forced.

That's a wee bit incoherent, I think.
 
}     Tenchi was dying, his body almost entirely reduced to ash in what 
} had ultimately been a futile display of... phenomenal stupidity. Not 
} that she could fault him. He had done what he believed in, which was 
} admirable, even if not successful.

"Tenchi had been dying", I think.

}     Ryouko fidgeted for a moment, her gaze darting from Yosho to Terry, 
} then back to Tenchi, as her smile slipped. "Nothing," she said after a 
} moment. "He finally ran away."
} 
}     Yosho raised an eyebrow at that, shaking his head dourly. "That boy? 
} I don't think he knows how to."

YOSHO:  I've been trying to teach him.  It's embarassing,
        really.  At least he knows how to levitate....
 
}     Washuu grimaced, explaining, "It's not that easy. Not everyone is in 
} the form that Ranma and Yosho are -- 

"shape" or "condition", rarely "form" in this context.

}     Pausing to gather herself, the woman explained, "Ranma-dono... had a 
} disagreement with Ryouko." She sighed, kneeling at Ranma's side, and 
} patting his head affectionately. "I'm... I am afraid that Ryouko was not 
} careful... and Ranma-dono has... died. He pushed himself too hard, On-- 
} He pushed himself too hard, Washuu-chan."

" -- he pushed himself" (no capital)
 
}     Tsunami sighed sadly. "Yes, but Ranma-dono... his human half was not 
} strong enough. His heart failed him, and he pushed himself too hard... 
} nothing of Ranma-dono remains as human."
} 
}     The redheaded scientist trembled, blinking away moistness in her 
} eyes. "Well," she said, struggling for control, "he never knew about the 
} chance that he had stolen from him, did he?"
} 
}     "Washuu-chan?" the other woman asked, cocking her head to one side. 
} Cologne merely watched, wondering what knowledge she could glean from 
} the pair.

This is a bit strange.  The first paragraph makes it seem
like Tsunami knows about Ranma's situation, the third
implies differently.
 
}     Flinching, Ranma managed a nod. "Yeah... yeah I did."

"Yeah... yeah, I did."  (Need a comma.)
 
}     Tsunami offered a hopeful smile to Cologne and Washuu, then clasped 
} her hands together, fading away into the column of light that teleported 
} her into one of the awaiting warships above. The redhead smirked to 
} herself, fighting back the more than a week of fatigue. 

That last bit is awkward. I'd suggest making it just
"fighting back more than a week of".

}     Washuu snorted, shaking her head. "Trust me," she remarked dryly, 
} "you haven't seen anything yet."
} 
}     The woman raised an eyebrow at that. "Oh?" she asked. "What will 
} happen next?"

WASHUU:  Behold... talking mimes!
 
}     Cologne shrugged thoughtfully. "Perhaps something to eat would be in 
} order. Do you like ramen?"

WASHU:  Banana ramen?  No, wait, sorry, that's not my dialogue.
 
}     Ryouko stalked towards the young man and the two women chatting with 
} him before the door to the building. Washuu had said to find Ranma, and 
} he was _probably_ in that building, but... "Excuse me," she said, 
} probably a little more brusquely than she had intended. Calming herself, 
} she tried again, "Excuse me, do you know where 'Ranma' is?"

Why is 'Ranma' in single quotes?
 
}     The boy stared at her, hard, and she was unable to meet his eyes, 
} gazing imperiously over his shoulder. "Well," she began slowly, "I, uh, 
} thought you were stronger than you were."

Why is he looking over his shoulder?  Weren't they facing off?
 
}     He furrowed his brow, and she looked away, idly toying with the same 
} strand of hair again. He sighed, deciding she had opted to leave him 
} alone with his thoughts, and watched as a van pulled up to the compound, 
} the tires scraping against the sidewalk before it came to a halt.

That's an awfully... safe parking job for Seta.
 
}     Terry shouted, "Seta!" Extending one fist as he dashed towards the 
} other man.
} 
}     Snapping his head to one side, Seta matched Terry's gesture, and the 
} two halted, fists meeting loudly, while Seta yelled, "Terry!"
} 
}     Yosho blinked, and the men embraced, pounding each other on the 
} back. "Man," Seta commented, pushing Terry away to look at him more 
} clearly, "I haven't seen you since I dropped out of the circuit!" He 
} shook his head, stepping back and grinning. "How have you been, Terry? 
} Did you finally win?"

Heh.
 
}     Ryouko waved a hand dismissively, "You get used to it. C'mon, follow 
} me." With that, she pointed at one of the Juraian warships, its 
} ponderous bulk still circling the harbor. "Let's race."
} 
}     Ranma grinned slowly. "You're on."

This was a good scene. 

}     But this story writes itself, so this is what you get for now. 
} Please find it in your hearts to forgive me. ^_^;;;

Only if you release the next chapter soon. :P

Good fic.  I had much less to say about the second half of
the fic, as it was quite solid.  The Washuu/Ryoko scene was
done very well, in my opinion; it captured the complicated
relationship between the two.

Bjorn

-- bjorn@etho.caltech.edu http://www.its.caltech.edu/~bjorn Computation & Neural Systems, Caltech 216-76, Pasadena CA 91125 .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List----. | Administrators - ffml-admins@anifics.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@anifics.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---- http://ffml.anifics.com/faq.txt -----'