Subject: [FFML] Re: [Fanfic][Child of Silence][Chapter 1]
From: Gary Kleppe
Date: 1/17/2001, 3:50 PM
To: Jeremy Evans
CC: ffml@fanfic.com

    [The following text is in the "iso-8859-1" character set]

    [Your display is set for the "US-ASCII" character set]

    [Some characters may be displayed incorrectly]



Jeremy Evans wrote:



Part 1: The players take the stage



AZUSA: This stage is MINE! Claudette! Claudette!



Chapter 1 - First Impressions



When dad got back from China he was feeling pretty low so



Dad (capitalize when used as a name)



low, so



Grandpa decided to cheer him up with a fianc�. Grandpa



fiancee



(Two "e"s when you're talking about a female; and please don't use non-ascii

accent characters, as they're not standard across platforms.)



Never was any good at understanding people. Grandma went



never (no reason to capitzlize this)



along to smooth things over with the Tendos and to

Make sure the girls were worthy of her son. Grandma



make (same here)



Used to have some crazy ideas about manliness but



used (and here)



She kind of let it slide with Dad because of the burden



she (and here)



He bore. She did at least expect him to give the



he (and here)



engagement a try. Interestingly they didn't tell



Interestingly, they



him about until they were on the way to the Tendo home.



about it until



I guess even grandma has her brain farts.



NODOKA: It's not polite to mention farts in public, dear.



Mr. Tendo did the same thing. I later asked his

daughters how they reacted. All told they took



told, they



It pretty well...



it

 

"WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU NEVER

MEET HIM!!!!"



met	(unless Shampoo is a Tendo daughter in this AltUniv)



IMO, four exclamation points and all caps is going overboard with the emphasis.

If you want to impress us with how loud the shout is, a better way is to

describe in words how loud it is.



Soun shrunk back from his youngest. The

News she'd be sharing mastery of the dojo



news



With another hadn't gone quite as well as



with



He'd hoped, the fact he hadn't meet Ranma



he'd hoped; the



Had made things worse."



had



"She has a point daddy." Nabiki began "Besides I'm sure



point, Daddy," Nabiki began. "Besides, I'm



we'd all feel better about this if you'd meet this boy



met



before." Kasumi nodded slowly in agreement.



Soun laughed nervously "Well, I'm sure he'll



nervously.	(missing a period)



Be fine, he is the son of a dear friend of mine after



be fine. He



All."



all."



"Great another stupid BOY to deal with." The youngest



"Great, another



with," the



Tendo said under her breath.



Nabiki looked like she was about to say more when

Someone knocked on the door.



someone



The accidental rhyme (more, door) here makes the sentence awkward. You might

want to change the wording.

 

"That must be them now." With a smile on his face

and a spring in his step Soun Tendo sprang from



step, Soun



his seat.



A few moments later the sound of a door opening could

Be heard. Followed by a few muffled voices then by



be heard, followed



or



be heard. It was followed



the Sound of Soun Screaming and a body hitting the floor.



sound of Soun screaming

 

The Tendo daughters looked at one another before moving

To find out what happened.



to



At this point, I'm presuming Ranma's curse is something different than it is in

the manga. If he still has the same old gender-changing curse, there's no reason

for this extreme a reaction.



Water has an interesting way of finding my father at the most

Inopportune times. This was one them. Fortunately Grandma



innoportune



Fortunately, Grandma



Was able to settle everyone down and explain the situation.



was



After which Akane Challenged dad to a match. Dad was surprised,



Afterwards, Akane



(If you want to keep the "after which," combine this sentence with the previous

one.)



He'd figured most of Japan would know who and what he



surprised; he



or



surprised. He



Was by then. The truth was few did. The cover up had gone



was



Quite well. Seems they'd gotten a U.S. official to consult



quite



them on such matters. He really wasn't interested in fighting,

but Grandpa insisted so he consented. So after a little hot water

dad was ready to go.



Dad



Now to understand how good a fighter my father is, you

Should know that he trained against guys like Akira



should



For fun. Fighting people who can lift 3 tons and move



for



At over 800 mph has a tendency to force someone to improve



at



or fall hard. Dad improved.



Showing a scene where Ranma exibits his power would IMO be a better way to

establish it than having your narrator tell us about it.

 

****



Soun and the assembled families watched as the Akane took

A normal Karate stance while Ranma simply stood with



a



His arms behind his back and waited.



his



This is really annoying. Is it some setting in your word processor that keeps

capitalizing the beginning of lines?

 

Akane charged in with a right cross. Intending to fallow up



cross, intending to follow



with a snap kick to the groin. It was an obvious male weakness

after all. Besides if he wasn't smart enough to protect it he

shouldn't be a martial artist.



I hope there's something in your AltUniv premise to explain why Akane fights

dirty here.



With the same lazy yet lightening fast movement as before Ranma



lightning-fast	("lightening" is the process of becoming less dark)



Akane fumed. How dare he give her tips like she was a

beginner! she was Akane Tendo, Heir to the Tendo school



She



of anything goes Martial Arts! She didn't need this...

this..BOYS help.



this... BOY'S

 

"I can get up on my own!" She snapped.



she



Tendo nodded "Very good Ranma." He looked to Akane "I'd



nodded. "Very good,



Akane. "I'd



Say he's proven himself a Martial Artist, right Akane?"



say



right, Akane?"



Akane mumbled something as she got up that sounded

Like 'Right'



like "Right."

 

Soun smiled "Well then I guess all that's left is to



smiled.



choose one of my daughters."



Ranma shook his hand up "I think we need to talk about



up.



that. There's something else you should know about me

before then."



RANMA: I've got a terminal, highly communicable social disease. That's not a

problem, is it?



Soun was of course puzzled and looked to Genma, who looked

to his wife. Turning back Genma nodded "Yes old friend there



"Yes, old friend, there



is something else."



Not liking the sound of that one bit. Soun ushered everyone



bit, Soun



Once everyone was seated Ranma raised his right, which was

Encircled by a silver bracelet. Nabiki gasped.



encircled



"You're a special!" Once said the others in the family

reacted as well. Akane Vocally.



AKANE: Darn! A special! If I'd beaten you, I'd have gotten a free game!



"Ah HA!" She stood up shoving an accusing finger in his



up, shoving



Face "You cheated! You probably read my mind or are inhumanly



face.



fast."



Ranma actually became indignant "My powers do not work like



indignant.



that. And if they did I would not use them in an duel."



Akane sat down and snorted "Yeah right! First you change



snorted.



into a girl. And you probably spend hours in front of a

mirror with that. Now you can read minds. Probably force

girls to your lust, pervert!"



In the manga, Akane called Ranma a pervert because she found him in her bathroom

naked when she was expecting a girl. What possible reason could this version

have for it?



Now Ranma was appalled "That is WAY out of line! You just met me



appalled.



and are ready to condemn me like that!! You have no right!!!"



"Listen here pervert, if you think you can trick me..."



here,

 

The sound of someone clearing their throat forestalled



clearing her throat	(don't use "their" when you mean only one person)



further argument. All eyes turned to Nodoka. Who gave



Nodoka, who



"Now what my son is about to say

Does not leave this room. Understood."



does



The three girls nodded, Nabiki reluctantly.



She turned to Ranma "Go on son."



Ranma. "Go on, Son."



He smiled "Thanks mom." He turned to the Tendos "The power



smiled. "Thanks, Mom."



Tendos.



That was originally in my file was levitation. I can



that



levitate my self and whatever I'm in contact with about



myself



20 ft. off the ground. However not everything I can do



twenty feet off



(Don't use numerals or abbreviations in prose writing; they get in the way of

the reader trying to parse it.)



is in my file."



RANMA: I can juggle. I'm also good at tapdancing, and I'm learning the

accordion!



Nabiki paled as certain pieces fell into place. "Your



"You're



("Your X" means "the X belonging to you," not "you are.")



him. The one that killed Akira Kimoto with a single touch!"



Kasumi glanced from her sister to Ranma "Is that true?"



Ranma.



Ranma nodded slowly "Unlike the rest, my abilities stem



slowly.



from a control from the force that created us specials.

Through that I bring silence. None of the other specials



through



Have a clue as to what I could do before Akira. Now they



had a clue (no caps, and past tense)



know. Some may come after me knowing, correctly,

that I can and will take them down if they become a

threat humanity at large."



threat to humanity



Kasumi was white as sheet, while Nabiki was bringing



as a sheet



Herself under control. Akane looked disgusted, while



herself



Here Soun spoke up "Son, their will never be a better time.



Here, Soun spoke up.



There are already 3000 specials worldwide. As long as they



three thousand



exist you will be in some danger. This whole world could

one day be in danger because of a special. I would feel better

knowing a daughter of mine is married to a man who could save

her from one of those people if necessary."(1)



Please lose the footnote; direct author explanations should be avoided,

especially when they're no more than gratuitous digs at a character.



Ranma & Nodoka blinked in surprise. Not having expected him



Ranma and Nodoka



surprise, not



To take that attitude. Genma however smiled heartily and slapped



to



Genma, however,



his friend on the back. "Well Said Tendo! Well Said!"



"Well said, Tendo! Well said!"

 

Ranma looked at his mother who shrugged and then to the

Tendo girls. "Well what do you think?"



"Well, what



Kausmi's gaze rested on him for a long moment. He seemed

like a nice young man. Very responsible if he was willing

to carry out such a task at such a young age. The clincher

was his eyes. They seemed so hopeful. Like he needed

a few friend. She could guess why he felt that way.



friends.	("few" is plural)



She smiled warmly "I am curious about what it's like



warmly.



To be a special and it would be nice to have you and



to



your family over if nothing else. We get so few visitors

These days."



these

 

Kasumi was rewarded with a bright smile from the young

Saotome.



Nabiki took a far more calculating look. Secrets she couldn't revel,



reveal,



Minus. Potential to bring trouble minus. Might be convinced to



minus.



trouble, minus.



Start teaching a the Dojo big plus. Good Material for a book



start



dojo, big



material



Deal when this was over one-way or another, big Plus. Chance



deal



plus.



To have a handsome man on her arm for the world to see, major



to



Plus. Chance at friendship...undetermined.



Nabiki decided to take a chance "I'm not saying I'll marry him



chance.



but I'm willing to give it a try." If he did teach at the dojo maybe

she wouldn't have to pull anymore petty blackmails for a bit.



any more



It was getting hard to make money that way as people eventually

Wised up to her ploys. It was not like she was bothered by it morally



wised



Or anything.



or

 

She too was rewarded with a smile



Akane Stared at the man who beat her. He turned into a girl. He could



stared



Float in the air, which she was sure he'd somehow used to cheat.



float



And could kill with a touch. No Way.



way.

 

"I am not marrying some FREAK daddy! Who knows what he might



freak, Daddy!



Soun frowned "I apologize for my daughters behavior. I think



frowned.



daughter's



she's having a tough time at school. Anyway, as I understand



SOUN: I think the writer is getting her OOC. I'll talk to him about it.



your moving into the area?"



Nodoka spoke "Yes, I understand you wanted to reopen the Dojo



spoke.



so we decided to move here to make it easier for Genma and

Ranma to assist you."



Soun rubbed his chin "Wonderful! Now we'll let you kids get



chin.



to know each other. Ranma why don't you come by in the

morning and Nabiki can show you where the school is."



Gonna stop here. Though the grammatical mistakes are not exhausted, the C&Cer

is, and I think you get the point.



Frankly, your treatments of the characters are, so far, just not that

interesting. Ranma is a one-dimensional action hero type. Akane is a

one-dimensional violent maniac. We can argue over whether these treatments are

canon, and whether it matters, but the unfortunate truth is that these

treatments are just not that interesting to read about. Your Ranma just walks

dully through every conflict he gets involved in, and your Akane isn't likeable

enough for me to care what happens to her.



A hyper-powered Ranma *can* be done well; look at "Awakening of Demons" for a

good example. The important thing is that he still has a distinct personality,

and he gets involved in conflicts that challenge him, not only in fighting but

personally as well.



Finally, pay attention to your punctuation and capitalization. Doing these

things right is part of what makes a story readable, and if it isn't readable,

most people won't read it.



Hope this helps,





Gary





-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'