Subject: [FFML] Re: [fanfic][SM crossover] A General Time Paradox - Chapter 2
From:
Date: 12/12/2000, 11:20 AM
To: allyn yonge <ayonge@yahoo.com>, Nidoking <Matthew.P.Katinas@rose-hulman.edu>, ffml@fanfic.com

Hi,

Comments @@

Everything IMO, only.

If you like what I write and the

way I write then my C&C might

be helpful.

OTOH, you might be better off deleting

this stuff and reading the back of a cereal box.

^_*



Doubt that. Now lessee If I can put in my two monetary units.





    "Hard work or not, there has to be a way to beat

them," said Mina.

"Everyone has a weakness."

    "The problem is," put in Artemis, "your powers

were designed for

fighting the creatures of the Negaverse. If Ami's

right about these new

opponents not being from the Negaverse, you could

very well be in over

your heads with this fight!"



@@Personal POV. Looking at all 200 episodes of SM,

this doesn't _quite_ jibe. I can see how it _could_

work.

I have to agree. For the powers to be target-specific, is...

utterly stupid, IMO, for their powers were created BEFORE

the concept of Negaverse existed.

 



suffer if we don't keep fighting!"

    "If we do keep fighting, the people who suffer

will be us," said Rei

glumly. "We're going to need some kind of plan to

defeat them." Six

pairs of eyes turned to stare at Ami.

    "What?" asked Ami, sweatdropping. "I haven't got

a plan!"



@@IMO, "sweatdropping" or "sweatdrop" is

a fanfic convention that is better off NOT used.

I realize other writers use it, along with <shudder>

"facefault", but IMO . . .it's "cheating", a way to

avoid

developing real descriptions. 

MY POV only.



So, how would YOU describe a situation where someone

would sweat-drop or face-fault?





    "We're sunk, then," said Serena. "We might as

well give up now. If

even Ami can't think of a plan..."

    "Now wait just a minute!" shouted Ami. "Who says

I can't come up

with a plan? I haven't had any time to think of

one!"

    Lita clenched her fists. "Well, if our powers

are useless, we'll

just have to find some new powers!"

    "New powers?" asked Serena. "Where do we find

those?"



@@TV: "Come on down to Powers-R-Us! All this week,

Hyper-Beam-Destructo-Ray, only 9999.95 Yen. And to the

first one hundred customers . . .A brand new Magical

Girl 

Theme Song by Mayo Okamoto!"



But Sailor Moon's original transformation sequence has 

a groovy tune!





    "I think there's a way to rise to a higher level

of Sailor Scout

power," offered Luna, "but I can't seem to remember

what it is."

    "Neither can I," said Artemis. "I wish I

could... I've forgotten far

too much."



@@AMI: (thoughtfully) "There's some interesting new

research on how lowering testosterone levels improves

memory."



SERENA: " Really, how do you do that?"



AMI: "Castration"



ARTEMIS: "It's all coming back to me."



Heh.



 "They have not yet seen Ranma in this form.

She will be

registered as a transfer student at Crossroads

Junior High School."

    "Who's going to check out the other schools?"

asked Lina.

    "You will," replied Beryl. "A simple spell

should be enough to

obscure your bangles from mortal eyes and give you

the appearance of a

common schoolgirl at Grass Valley Junior High

School. We are quite sure

that most of the Sailor Scouts attend one of those

two schools."



@@RYOKO: "Why don't we just kill everyone

at both those schools??



BERYL: "You FOOL! That would reveal our presence to

the humans."



RYOKO: "Yeah, but the only ones who can stop you

would be dead."

Hey, it IS canon that QB is both insane and stupid.

Of course, it could be theorized that it was the 

remaining good in her fighting against what she 

had become, and she subconsciously fought against

her proclaimed goals... Hmm... there's a fic there to 

be written...





    "Then what do I get to do?" asked Ryoko.

    "Your part of the plan will become clear in

time. You will have the

most important part of all."

    "All right!" cheered Ryoko, slamming her fist

into her palm. "Now

THAT sounds more like it!"

    Beryl waved her arm, and a portal opened behind

them. "Ranma, Lina,

go. Keep your powers in check until you can discover

a likely candidate.

Once you think you have discovered a Sailor Scout,

isolate her from the

rest and confront her. Ryoko will assist you in

forcing her to reveal

her identity, and then you can destroy her."

    "What happens if the girl we find isn't a Sailor

Scout?" asked

Ranma.

    Beryl considered this. "Remove her from future

consideration."

    "What the heck's that supposed to mean?" asked

Ranma.

    "Isn't it obvious?" asked Lina. "Once she knows

who you really are,

we can't let her tell anyone else."

    "We're supposed to kill innocent girls? That

wasn't part of the

deal!"

    "The deal is anything I choose to make it," said

Beryl. "If you

value what the crystal holds, you will do as I say!"



@@Nicely sinister. 

Kinda Starwars-y. 

I'm currently betting it's Tenchi who's trapped by Beryl, as 

the reason for Ryoko's compliance... though there might be 

a twist there.

And unless this diverges from TM before Kagato, there's bound

to be intervention coming from either Washuu or Tsunami, if things

get too hairy. Unless, again. if you're going by the TV or Shin...

Hm. Read a while back, that Ryoko, when she matures, and with 

all the three gems, is equal in power with Tsunami...

Hm.



room, leaving

behind a confused and slightly irate Ryoko.

*************************************************

    "Good morning, class," said the teacher, waiting



Ranko

sighed. Having to kill innocent girls she could

probably learn to deal

with. Going to school was another thing altogether.



@@<ouch> That's cold. ^_*

Cute, but rather breaks the mood, IMO.

Might be the intention, though.



    Amelia examined Stephanie's cheerful smile and

long dark hair.

"Don't get me wrong. I'm not a very friendly

person."



@@Who is saying this? "Amelia"? Or Stephanie?



Actually, this is the point where I stopped reading. The name 

'Stephanie' overloaded my suspension of disbelief. 

Not your fault by any means. I know this is placed in the dubverse, 

so I should deal... Which rises the question: how can Ranma&company

be speaking English? Ah, nevermind that. I'll just get my headache. 

It's easier than thinking about the convoluted crossings.



   

    "Really?" asked Serena. She cast a quick glance

at Ami and swallowed

the food in her mouth. "I can't imagine a school

tougher than

Crossroads."

    "Oh, you'd better believe it!" said Ranko. "The

Principal of

Furinkan was a lunatic!



@@Mixing English with Japanese names.

IMO this is VERY annoying. Why not just 

stick with Japanese throughout? 



nodnod.

Though, there might arise continuity problems, if your 

knowledge comes from the dub. There probably are some 

subtle characterisation differences.





    "Judo, eh? I study mostly kempo myself. It might

be interesting to

see how our styles interact." And to meet some of

your other friends,

she didn't add aloud.

Actually, Ranma does little kenpo, specifically Shojinri

Kenpo, which is basically an okinawan version of the 

Shaolin Kungfu, though this is oversimplifying things.

This can be seen in his most basic stances and punches,

while Akane seems to be using some style of mainland

Karate.











@@A nice bit of dialogue. Flowed fairly smoothly.

More importantly if flowed _naturally_, as if

people were really speaking and interacting.

Not perfect, BUT . . .feels very natural. You want

to try to get ALL of your dialogue and scenes

to flow smoothly and naturally at this level or

better.  IMO, use this bit as your standard

of comparison for the rest of your writing.

This should be the baseline. You want

everything at this level or above. 

Good work.

		^_O

I agree. I'll be reading the next chapter, certainly.



------------------------------------------------------------



<SNIP>



Overall: C+

(A+ would be Krista Perry or Jamie and Bridget Wilde)

Remember, this is a subjective grade.

Sticking to either Japanese or English names, and some more 

research to the Smoon background and concepts, and you'd

get a 'B' from Allyn, I bet ^.^





LOVE the pun in the title, btw. I only wish I could do

things like that.



nodnod.



________________________________________________________________

Ilmainen Internet @ http://www.nic.fi/







-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'