Subject: [FFML] Re: [FIC][NEW!]R.5] Amazing Spiderman Issue Ten
From: Ryoga P Hibiki
Date: 11/16/2000, 2:43 AM
To: Jedediah@tri-countynet.net
CC: ffml@fanfic.com



        First off I'd like to say that I've enjoyed this so far. It's a

really good idea. The first eight parts or so are dead on.



        Secondly, I'd like to point out several major problems with the

new stuff. I realize that this is an alterniverse and all, and involves

Ranma. You're changing things a bit and that's cool. Just don't do too

much. I've pointed out some of the major things that don't sit well with

me, it seems you've rushed the Venom story out for some reason.



        One: This isn't Venom at all. It's Carnage. Venom is sick,

twisted, and completely devoted to destroying Spiderman for crimes

committed against both the Symbiote, and Eddie Brock. [Rejecting the

Symbiote, and basically killing Brocks career.] Carnage is evil,

calculating, and much more in tune with the way you've portraid the

symbiote in your fic. The Symbiote actually likes Brock, it's not just

using him the way this thing is using Kuno. Venom also sees himself as a

hero of sorts. Something that doesn't seem possible the way you have them

now.



        Two: Why skip the black costume story? It's important. It sets

the stage for Venom's hatred of Spiderman, and the psycotic lengths that

he'll go to get his revenge. Plus it gives Spiderman important background

information on fighting Venom later on.



        Three: Venom doesn't set off Spiderman's Spider Sense. Period.

That's one reason that Brock bothers him so much. Gosunkugi can put

together that something is wrong with Kuno without his powers. The way

you've made him it would be easy to figure that out. Ranma and Akane both

did, why not him? He's delt with Kuno before, and seems to be pretty

aware of what's going on in Furinkan.



        Four: Kuno was in no way involved with Mousse kidnapping Akane.

There's no real reason for him to know anythijng about it, much less have

memories of it.



        I suggest a complete rewrite of the past three chapters. Why you

might ask?



        Because Ryoga is the perfect host for the Venom Symbiote. He's

gone often enought that he could fill the roll easily, he can just show

up when he's needed and vanish just as easily and nobody would suspect.

His character is much more in tune with the roll. [Please don't make him

Kraven!]



        He'd see himself as a hero easily despite the things he does.

Especially freeing Akane from Ranma. Another important reason is his size

fits. He's muscular already, he's really strong, and  his depressed

attitude would make him a much more capable and willing recipient of the

symbiote than Kuno. He'd just look the roll better really, Kuno's too

tall and too thin. Plus Ryoga has the right background to fill the role

without killing Venom off, [You'll proably have to the way you have it

now.] The wandering over violent dark hero who hates Spiderman [and

Ranma.] It would be easy enough for Ryoga to get angry with Gosunkugi.

His own feelings for the girl, plus taking pictures of her in secret.



        I suggest you keep Kuno in the role he has now, just much later

on as Carnage. He's perfect for it. Crazy, and easily manipulated by the

evil and much more controling Symbiote that appears later. Carnage's

symbiote would think nothing fo dumping Cassady if the need arose, but

Venom's Symbiote is much more loyal than that. Just have the Venom

symbiote spawn at a fight in Furinkan. That would be pretty easy to do.



        I can see that you're probably planning on making Carnage

Kodachi. That's cool too, but Kuno would be better as she's mostly a

running gag more than anything else. She's crazy and maybe psycotic

enough to do it though. She's also a little smarter than Tatewaki, but

that could work against the Symbiote more than anything else.



        Keep it up, it's really good despite the rushed appearance of the

last three chapters. I hope to see more of this soon!



        Ja! 



        Carrot Glace





-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'