Subject: [FFML] Re: [BGC] [FANFIC] Drunkard's Walk II, Chapter 7
From: "Brian Payne" <sofaspud@sofaspud.org>
Date: 2/25/2000, 3:09 PM
To: <rms@eclipse.net>, "Fanfic Mailing List" <ffml@fanfic.com>


<snip fic>

    Well, hell!  What rock have -I- been hiding under that made
me miss -this-?

    (goes back and reads the rest of the series - mostly)

    Very good work, here.  One thing that bugs me a bit, though
was this: in one of the previous chapters, Lisa
officially -joined- the Knight Sabers, yes?  If that's the case,
why is she so... well, secretive, I guess... about sharing
information with them?  I got the idea that that was, partially,
her job.

    If I were Sylia, I'd be pretty po'ed.  I mean, she extended
some MAJOR trust, and this is how she's repaid?

    Maybe I'm reading it wrong, but from my POV, Lisa's behavior
is way unacceptable.  If she's a Knight Saber, her first priority
should be the team, just like everyone else.  Right now, though,
her first priority seems to be herself/her career, then Doug, and
THEN the Knight Sabers.  IMO, she's behaving a little like a
spoiled brat. :)  She wants her toys FIRST, and THEN she'll think
about sharing.  Her only redeeming factors to me are that she has
been capable of keeping the Knight Sabers secrets - hard for a
journalist! - and that I like her character, although I still
don't agree with her behavior. :)

    I guess my question would be this: am I reading it wrong?  If
so, then I'd suggest a little touch-up work... I'm willing to go
into more depth in private mail, if you'd like.  If I'm not
reading it wrong, then, man, you are cruel! :)  Personally, I'd
never have thought of using Lisa as yet another conflict source.

    Either way, it's still great work.  I'm really looking
forward to more of this!


    Brian Payne
    sofaspud@sofaspud.org
    http://www.sofaspud.org



-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'