Subject: [FFML] [C&C] [Hime-chan] Pale Reflection
From: Marcus Fong
Date: 2/9/2000, 9:47 PM
To: Scott Schimmel
CC: ffml@fanfic.com

Congratulations. An excellent concept, and well-executed too!
(And the fact that it's Hime-chan is a bonus.)

Okay, on to the C&C:

	No, that's not true.  That little girl was another
person.

Very nice. =)

	So I almost cried, almost.  And instead, I half-turned
to glance at him.  Daichi.  He hasn't changed a bit.  He
looks quite dashing in formal wear.  Although he didn't seem
entirely comfortable.  And his expression was almost one of
boredom.  But that's just the way he is; he always has been

The number of short sentences make Daichi's description sound
a bit clipped. In my opinion, it might flow a bit better if
a few were merged.

	That was a surprise.  No, not the kiss; that Manami
would ever be so serious about one man.  It wasn't that she
didn't like Tetsu-kun; quite the contrary, obviously.  She
just liked Daichi, too.  And Hiroshi-kun.  And
Morita-sempai.  And... I've forgotten his name; the sempai
on the soccer team.  And Sei-sama.  And dozens more.  She
was rather infamous for it.

	Anyway, I guess she and Tetsu-kun finally had bounced
off of each other often enough that they decided to try
holding onto each other instead.  And they're a cute couple. 
I'm sure they'll be happy.

I'm impressed. The "bounced off" part works very well. Nice
monologue.

	Afterward, Manami lobbed the bouquet practically right
toward her friend I-chan and me.  I stretched like everyone

"Her friend I-chan" sounds a little odd, since it's 
established directly after this that I-chan and Himeko's double 
are friends as well.

	It was a wonderful day.  If only it hadn't led directly
into this.

	Now, we stand before a wooden door in a sterile
hallway; even the lighting seems pale and antiseptic.

A well-timed tense change. The immediacy it brings to the second 
part really adds to the emotion of the scene.

	"Hai," I whisper back, and embrace the magic as it
crashes over me.

...and a terrific ending line, as well. Great stuff.

Don't know what brought that on, really.

I can only echo on that one: hope it happens again soon. =)

--Marcus



-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'