Subject: [FFML] Re: Collected Comments 5 [C&C]
From: "Rebeka Thomas" <ranko_1_2@hotmail.com>
Date: 11/19/1999, 7:50 PM
To: "FFML" <ffml@fanfic.com>

Description:  Nabiki proves, once again, that she is an
irresistable gaijin magnet.

Comments:  There's a fair bit of Mary Sue about this story

LOL i just pictured a little-miss-perfect type girl as a marine.

but it's mechanically sound.  I liked the depiction of
Tofu at work, but I have doubts about the depiction of
Nodoka.  I mean, c'mon, if the old man's training techniques
didn't break or embitter Ranma, what could Nodoka do?
Also, Kasumi, being a traditional sort, would not likely
approve of or encourage Nabiki's interest in a foreigner.
Soun would plotz.

"plotz?"

Description:  Human bad guys show up.

?

Comments:  The spell checker is not your friend...

At least he ran it. there's not a single mis-spelled word in there!

Subject:
            [FFML] [shortfic] [SI parody?]
       Date:
            Mon, 08 Nov 1999 22:08:13 -0600
       From:
            Kichigai <kichigai@ipa.net>

Description:  Lina Inverse otaku finds that she is better
admired from a long long way away.

Comments:  Much better than the average self insertion,
and it's short.  However the line formatting was quite
bad.

Subject:
        [FFML] (no subject)
  Date:
        Mon, 8 Nov 1999 20:49:47 -0500
  From:
        "Rebeka Thomas" <ranko_1_2@hotmail.com>

Description:  Ranma is plonked into the Odyssey.

Comments:  The author's habit of addressing the audience
directly is more irritating than amusing.

Live with it. 's that simple. i think it's funny, and i can't think
of any other way to use the word "dickweed" in a fanfic [i will in
the inline-authors-notes in the next one]

Also, casting
Ranma as the voice of good sense strikes me as odd.

well, come on!!! he's read the book, he's seen the movie, he's got
the t-shirt. [kidding on t-shirt, may not be on movie] he knows damn
well what will happen to Odysseus if he yells at Polyphemus.



Subject:
         [FFML] [Ranma] A Matter of Romantic Chemistry - Part 4
    Date:
         Mon, 08 Nov 1999 00:00:46 -0800
    From:
         Jack Staik <jstaik1043@earthlink.net>

Description:  Ranma's separated cursed form turns out
to be his sister after a fashion.

after a different fashion then previously assumed, you mean.

Comments:  Kasumi's attitude toward Nodoka is internally
contradictory.  That isn't necessarily a problem, but
Kasumi should be a little more aware of the conflict between
"No mother would do it" and "Honour demanded it".



Subject:
        [FFML] [Fanfic] [SM] [SI-almost-parody] Blue Without You -
chapter 1
  Date:
        Tue, 9 Nov 1999 19:11:35 -0600
  From:
        "Kevin Callahan" <kionon@hotmail.com>

Description:  Kevin Callahan suddenly gets his very own
Ami Mizuno.

Comments:  Well, so far it isn't funny.  I'll have to wait
and see just what the "madness and chaos" is.

SI-Parodies seem to be all the rage these days. and the starting
spark was better then the original SI. [Need i mention Oscar?]

Subject:
        [FFML] [fic][Soap][revised]Cyan: Nobuyuki Muyo!
  Date:
        Wed, 10 Nov 1999 10:06:40 +0800
  From:
        TimeRunner <keiichi@i-manila.com.ph>

Description:  Not very changed from the last time so far
as I can tell.

Comments:

Nobuyuki:  So you made me think you were going to kill
me to cheer me up?

Ryoko:  Yup!  Worked too.  Don't you feel a lot more
cheerful now that you aren't going to be killed?

HAHA! too bad i'm not gonna read soap till a rainy day.

Subject:
        [FFML] [fic][Soap][revised]Yellow: All-Purpose Cultural
Mecha Boy Ryu-Kun
  Date:
        Wed, 10 Nov 1999 10:07:47 +0800
  From:
        TimeRunner <keiichi@i-manila.com.ph>

Description:  Also apparently unchanged.

Comments:  Kiyone's motivation is still cloudy as written.
>From what you told me she doesn't have the corporate
loyalty that she expresses in this, but rather a personal
loyalty.

Subject:
         [FFML] [Fanfic][X-over] An Unlikely Couple (Chapter 2)
    Date:
         Wed, 10 Nov 1999 00:17:39 -0600
    From:
         Kent Hyam <rodney.hyam@sk.sympatico.ca>

Description:  Various Ranma 1/2 martial artists out of
ego or lovesickness decide that they have to help the
Senshi.

Comments:  Some sloppiness produced by haste and lack of
pre-reading.

    Minako was about to continue, but subsided when she caught
sight of
the expression on Michiru's face.  "We don't no that she had
anything al
all to do with the Silver Millennium," Ami commented calmly.

"know" "at".  And may I take this moment to sincerely hope
that they don't turn out to be reincarnations.  There's no
reason why our era can't turn out some tough customers.
Also that should probably be the look on Haruka's face,
since it's Haruka feeling the pangs of jealousy, isn't it?

   "As I recall, each of the Senshi headed a group of elite
warriors
that aided them in their duties."  After she finished, Luna
smiled
smugly, happy show Artemis up.

"to show"  And how did that show Artemis up?

Luna typically gets bugged by artemis about her amnemonia [lack of
memory, as opposed to loss of it]

    "Right.  Plus, there was a dojo near the last attack.  It's
the
article beside the add that's the real proof though."

"ad"

And that crack about martial artists not spending their
time doing tea ceremony or eating was funny.

really funny considering he was talking about Sentarou Daimonji and
Piccolet Chardin! don't forget to add "playing around at the skating
rink"

You know if Argentite just reasons with Taro, he could
be a real asset.  He has toyed with the thought of taking
over the world after all, and it would be his chance to
rename himself after a mineral.

Nah. probably would end up with a lame-ass name like Pantyhosite.

Subject:
         [FFML] [Pok�mon] POK�GENIE Ch 10
    Date:
         Tue, 16 Nov 1999 23:51:19 GMT
    From:
         "Tom Mathews a.k.a. Disruptor" <godphoniex@hotmail.com>\

Description:  The weather turns dangerously bad, just as
Ash decides to limit his array of pokemon.

Comments:  I'd think that Misty's wish ability would limit
the amount of real danger they are in.  So when is Misty
going to win a fight by having Ash wish for a large anvil
above her opponent's head?

Ash doesnt fight dirty like that!

       Bill, wincing, said, "Professor, don't you think that
show is in bad
tatse?"

"taste"

Fusion idea when i saw this scene: "Billigan's Isle." Oak as the
Professor and Bill as Gilligan!

nah.

  Under the waves, Team Rocket's sub was being rocked by the
storm as well.

Uh...no.  A surface storm doesn't endanger submerged subs.

There's still the nauseating circular water currents, isnt there?

       Ash shrugged, as he was a bit startled to her anything
coming from
Charizard.  He hoped that the time out of the ball would make
Charizard more

"hear"

It appears that Misty is no longer worried about the idea
of evolving into an efreet.  When will she start saying
"Gee-ni-ee"?

Subject:
        [FFML] [Fanfic][TM!] Vacation Days chapter 5
  Date:
        Thu, 18 Nov 1999 01:42:34 -0500
  From:
        "DB Sommer" <sommer@3rdm.net>

Description:  Mihoshi demonstrates that she really is a
better person to be shipwrecked with than Gilligan.

Comments:  Actually mammalian herbivores and carnivores
taste like beef.  Mammalian omnivores
(including humans) tend to taste like pork.  Reptiles and birds
taste like chicken.  Giant arthropods would taste like
crayfish.

Whatever you say, Hannibal.

"I, ah, I didn't mean you," Tenchi said as lamely as possible.

The tone of his lie made Mihoshi look at him curiously. "Are you
hearing

But Tenchi didn't lie.

"Oops," Mihoshi said as she realized what she had done. She
handed the
laser wire back to Tenchi. "It's a good thing they pack spares
rods."

"spare rods"

victory would be Malgaunt's. "She's the best flyer among us, and
we really
need you here to make keep giving orders to the others." He hoped
Stargrave

delete "make"

"I didn't bother me at all," she finally managed to get out.

"It"

"I'm not gay!" Tenchi shouted.

"I didn't say you are," Mihoshi said in surprise at the uncalled
for
accusation. "I didn't think it either. I just assumed you were
being a

what, WHAT?! i didn't read this! pervert? hermaphrodite [barf at
memories of oscar]? gynophobe?

That's a protestation, not an accusation.

Subject:
        [FFML] [FFML][Slayers][character sketch][WAFF alert] One
Day
  Date:
        Wed, 17 Nov 1999 21:30:48 -0800
  From:
        Murasaki Kaze <muteki@juno.com>

Description: Two people try to get up the nerve to confess
their affections.

Comments:  Not as WAFFY as it seems, more ironic I'd say.
Some sloppy formatting.

Subject:
        [FFML] [FIC][R.5] The Omega Project Part One, 1 of 2
  Date:
        Wed, 17 Nov 1999 22:27:20 -0500 (EST)
  From:
        Jed M Bidwell <Jedediah@tri-countynet.net>

Description:  A clone of Ranma's female form wakes up in
a dark future.

Comments:  While Ranma's breasts are substantial, at least
by Japanese standards, they aren't _that_ big.  Have the
clones been tinkered with?  I should think the reason why
she was enjoying trashing the would-be rapists would be
self-evident even if the source of the ability to do so is
a mystery to her.  This is vaguely reminiscent of a certain
other Ranma project with many authors, but since that one
has gone down the tubes, I look forward to seeing more
of this one.



-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'