Subject: Re: [FFML][fanfic][Ranma 1/2] The Soul Of A Samurai
From: Michael Noakes
Date: 4/21/1999, 2:47 PM
To: Miko
CC: Fanfic Mailing List <ffml@fanfic.com>


	Hi!

	Just figured I'd drop a few comments, while I'm back on the ML...

	You wondered in your intro to the fic if this angle had been taken
before; I seem to remember a few comedic spamfics on the subject, but no
serious efforts (am I right/wrong here?).  So you've got something
interesting here, and well written, too.
	I just found it resolved a bit quickly: not in the death of Kuno
(cutting away from the actual sword-stroke worked well), but just in the
sudden revelation of Ranma's identity, everyone passing out, the conflict.
I dunno, maybe a few more glimpses, a bit more suspensful build-up
would've helped?
	Actually, the only problem I have -- and it's not with your fic
specifically, but of stories of this type in general -- is, why?  I mean,
if you were a sorcerer of untold might and age, would you really waste
your time tormenting and manipulating high-school teens?  (It's like the
classic RPG setup: the omnipotent wizard/lich who constructs a baffling --
and highly unlikely -- dungeon, to 'test' adventurers.  I mean, how bored
do you have to be?
	Ummm... but I liked the fic!

	-Mike Noakes
*********************************************************
"We are but of yesterday, and we know nothing		*
	for our days on earth are but a shadow.		*
Will they not teach you and tell you			*
	and utter words out of their understanding?"	*
							*
	Job 8.9-10 (NRSV)				*
*********************************************************
E-mail: noakes_m@hotmail.com
Webpage: www.geocties.com/Tokyo/Subway/9701/