Jed Bidwell wrote:
Ummm, I never got a chance to pubically acknowledge Jed's apology from
awhile back. I just want to say thanks, I'm honored you even thought the mistake
was worth correcting or draw attention to. Of course, to keep this from being
complete spam, I'll make a few comments before I go-go.
Title: Downward Spiral
Series: Ranma 1/2
Genre: Sadfic
Author: Jed Bidwell
Email: jedediah@tricountynet.net
Summary:
Ryoga Hibiki committs suicide, leaving Ranma to wonder why. Ranma's
quest for answers leads him somewhere he wouldn't expect...
{Paul}
<snip>
which is as it should be. 15 or 16 out of 20... nice work for
someone whose name I didn't instantly recognize.
Thanks. I've read quite a few fanfics where a Ranma character
committs suicide, especially Ryoga, but they mostly came out the same. Ranma
& Akane got hitched...Ryoga gets depressed...suicide by some means or
Insert innocent whistle here...
another. Also, most are told from his viewpoint (not that there's anything
wrong with that). I wanted to do something different with the idea, so I
told it from Ranma's point of view, and left the reasons vague.
Side comment, strangely enough, one of the reasons a certain Ryouga/Suicide
fic is being written is telling the Ranma/Akane matchup from the other
character's perspectives... Ukyo, Ryouga, Mousse and Shampoo were all... I'll
refrain from saying targeted... apt as that may be ^_^;;
Note for those who actually care, NO, this is not a foreshadowing of what
the ending may be, just pointing out some rather juicy irony. The character's
fates, as always, is still anyone's guess... mine being the only assured one.
^_-
<snip>
Parts two and three are still good, but not as deep into the whys
as they could go; Ranma as forensic psychologist works, but the
reasons for the suicide don't deviate from the standard Ranma 1/2
storyline. This needed an extra kick, something unforeseen, to
make it shocking. I like it, but an ending as unexpected as the
finish to "The Bitter End" would be better (I don't mean it needs
violence, but something surprising). Overall, much better than
most of the "Ryouga offs himself" fics.
...we have our own genre now? O_o
Does that mean our own webpage, secret handshakes, T-shirts, hand crafted
alcholic beverages? Wai! Come on everyone, off a Piggy today... ummm, though as
a deacon of COR I must strongly protest
Really? I tried, but that was the best ending I could come up with.
Any suggestions how how the ending could be improved?
Thanks for all your input! I really appreciate it.
Ummm, any chance you could send me an extra copy of Downward Spiral? It
seems to have gotten lost in the last great crash of 1998... I hope that is...
still have a few days... <looks to his hardrive nervously>
Not that this is a fic request of any sort... no, really... honest... sigh
-_-
Revenge's End Mad Bad Bishonen Lad
Caretaker of the Dark and Lonely Place (COR Deaconate)
The Parrot King
(And the Moon was as blood, the Storms crashed and the Seas BOILED!)
(Typical, thought the Lobsters)
/
Oo
(~, )
V