Subject: Re: [FFML] Ranma nibun no ichi - 9 - H is for Hinako
From: Caroline Seawright
Date: 8/27/1998, 5:52 AM
To: Christopher Angel
CC: fanfic@fanfic.com

A new chapter of the first Lemon I ever read!  WAI!

Cool. ^_^  I'm honoured - my lemon was the first! ^_^

OK, C&C...

1) Of all the chapters of this fic, I liked this one the most.  It had the

Thank you.

most believable character work so far, especially in delaing with Cologne,
Mousse, Shampoo, Hinako, and Gos. (No, I can't spell his name, it's 2 AM.)

See? It didn't star Ranma and Akane again! ^_^

I wanted to focus on some of the others, this time... though it didn't
really go into too much detail with Shampoo and Mousse, but thanks! ^_^

2) All that said, something about the final 1/3 or so with Cologne, Hinako
and Gos seemed flat. (Not that way, you ecchi!)  There seemed to be a lack

*grin*

of...well...reality.  Nothing really sparked my imagination or really got me
into the character's heads.   Gos' self-loathing and all probably did the
best job of really seeming sincere, and even that struck my as being a
little detached.

I know. I was in quite a hurry to finish it... I've tried to fix it up, so
it's better than how I originally wrote it - MUCH better. But I don't know
what more to do to it to fix the last 1/3 or so up. (But I think I'll
leave Gosunkugi and his self loathing alone...)

The ending has changed from something super really, really un-natural to
something a little more like 'reality' (or as close to as my 'fics get!)

3) Tarou's bit was good.  Nice to see someone else using him.  (I still lay
claim as the #1 person to ever use him in a long fic. ^_^) Oh, Speaking of
Tarou: WAI!

Probably have to do a 'fic with him in it, some time in the future. ^_^
(Since not many other people do it...)

Kun-chan...
--
**********************************************************
* http://www.ecr.mu.oz.au/~caseawr                       *
* http://www.ecr.mu.oz.au/~caseawr/cor.html              *
* http://www.ecr.mu.oz.au/~caseawr/kunoichi/fanfics.html *
*++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++*
* High Priestess of the Church of Ryouga      (COR)      *
**********************************************************