Subject: Re: [FFML] [REVIEW] [SM] Davies on Fanfic (First Edition)
From: David Lerman
Date: 6/30/1997, 3:15 AM
To: Chris Davies , fanfic@fanfic.com

At 05:44 PM 6/29/97 -0600, Chris Davies wrote:
[Rant warning.  Ranma fanfic writers:  Consider that.  Every week, a
*megabyte* or so of Sailor Moon fanfic is released.  The only reason that
this isn't more noticeable is that most of it is *only* placed on Luna and
Artemis', the most influential of all Sailor Moon fanfic websites.
Consider what would happen to the Sailor Moon directory at the raac
archive if all that was released to raac instead ... and be a little more
humble, please.  End of rant.]

   Obvious troll.

   Are we supposed to be impressed at the quantity or that few of these
authors submit their stories for C&C in forums such as the FFML?  The
authors who post to the FFML, regardless of the series that serves as
inspiration, seek criticism and feedback so that they can improve the story
and improve their overall writing skills.  How many of the authors who
collectively produce this weekly *megabyte* of SM fanfiction submit their
creations to prereaders?  How many use C&C to revise and polish their
stories?  I doubt that a megabyte of fanfiction can be C&C'd and revised
every week. 

   
   With all due respect to the late Ted Sturgeon, his generalization, like
most such rules, breaks down in the particular.  For example, the fanfic
devotees of KOR, who produce an insignificant volume by comparison to SM,
can be proud that so much of their work is represented by well written
stories such as Kimagure Orange College.  

                                                                     dml