At 05:53 PM 5/14/1997 -0400, OtakuLoki@aol.com wrote:
In a message dated 97-05-14 17:46:35 EDT, you write:
<<
I had this idea for a Ryoga tale but so far all that's come to me is the
basic
outline:
1. Ryoga is mistakenly accused of raping Akane when she's found comatose and
naked and bound with a bandanna.
2. The others are so angry at what happened to Akane that they drag Ryoga to
Jusenkyo and throw him into Pool of Drowned Girl, removng his pig-curse and
giving him the girl-curse, then rape him as an act of revenge. (Note: Ryoga
gets pregnant.)
3. Ryoga is found to be innocent after all, but not until Akane finally
wakes
up seven months later.
4. Ryoga dies in childbirth.
Suggestions are very welcome.
A darkfic.
Stick with the plotline you have here. From what I've seen so far of the
actual story, it needs to slow down a bit; include more story between the
major plot points.
You're going to get a lot of flames for it, but don't worry about it. Were
you on the ML last time a main character died of childbirth? Trust me,
you'll get through it okay.
>>
Sorry. I don't see that this idea is at all appealing. First off, given
that Ranma et. al are inclined to jump to conclusions, I still think that
they are unlikely give Ryouga no chance to defend himself at all. Or give
Try this:
One of the other guys (or a girl angry enough to get the drowned-guy curse)
goes insane or evil and rapes Akane. He frames Ryoga, and works hard to
convince everyone else that Ryoga is guilty. He decides he wants to rape
again; no one cares if Ryoga gets hurt so guess who's the second victim?
some kind of justification. Second and more importantly, I cannot see any
males of the Ranma willing to rape anyone, especially a former boy, as
punishment for rape. Kill, yeah, that I can see. but not rape. It is just
too baroque.
Not for punishment, maybe, but for the same stupid excuses used to justify
attacking Akane?
Part of it is, my reaction to the idea of rape (hang the bastards) but
part of it is that I don't believe that any of the Ranma characters could do
it.
So the characterizations will need to be developed beyond their manga and
anime versions.