Looking at this C&C I felt obliged to answer it....
Although this is a responce to a particulair fic it does meet with the
criteria of covering a vast number of works of fiction....
So with no further pause....
On Wed, 16 Apr 1997, ROBERT MORRISON wrote:
Date: Wed, 16 Apr 1997 03:33:14, -0500
From: ROBERT MORRISON <SQUN29A@prodigy.com>
Subject: [FFML] Some C&C again....
Resent-Date: Wed, 16 Apr 1997 08:36:11 -0400
Resent-From: fanfic@fanfic.com
Time for a little more C&C:
Now, I'm going to give the benefit of the doubt that this MIGHT be an
alternate-reality fic in which only the first two series of
Sailormoon happened. However, I saw no indication of this other than
the fact that three seasons of the series were completely ignored.
I think that the whole point of fan fiction assumes that there are
alternate worlds/things happening...If we were to assume that fan fiction
did consider everything as cannon then we would be in a hell of alot of
trouple and I would be writing a lot more STAR TREK: THE NIGHT CREW
episodes....just a bunch of people sitting around drinking coffee while
nothing happened....
> > And once more I must protest the usage of the DIC
>names for the
characters. People, if you are GOING to write Sailormoon fanfiction,
USE THE RIGHT NAMES. Serena, Lita, Amy, Raye, Mina, Darien, Reeny,
Molly, Chad, Andrew, Melvin, and others--DO NOT EXIST. Nor do the
Sailor Scouts exist. Use the correct names or don't bother at all.
Actually these people do exist...
(well in a fictional sense....) You see if this is all someone has
experienced (aside from say, works of fan fiction... then yup this is
correct....)
You might as well say there is no such thing as ROBOTECH as it's just the
basterd offspring of MACROSS and the rest of the SDF series (well except
for ORGUS).
I think that naming is the province of the writer...
If you don't like it don't read it or use a universal text search and
chang it yourself...but don't tell the authors to change it. It's their
reality..not yours...
> I have mixed feelings about this story. I would feel a lot
better
about it if the author did a nice litle rewrite of part one and fixed
some of the naming and continuity errors, or explained that the thing
is an alternate universe fanfic.
I've answered this above...
Well that's all from me on this subject...
Hell, I'm in the middle of a SM/Stormbringer story which COULOD be part
of the original series...AND which contains BOTH Serena and Usagi...
Robyn....
From Amber where all realities are
possible. -if conceved by
one of the blood.
___________________________________________________________________________
Nene Nene Nene Nene Nene Nene Nene Nene Nene
I met a Lady in the Meads,
Full beautiful, a faery's child,
Her hair was long, her foot was light
And her eyes were wild.
J.Keats
________________________________________________________________________
Agent Of Chaos. Robyn, Duke of Amber. Unicorn Knight
****************************************************************************