On Fri, 25 Oct 1996, bridget ellen engman wrote:
Ranma would tell me to cut the poetic crap.
I really like this beginning.
Thanks.
"Thanks Nabiki! It's so pretty!" I stopped to look at myself in
the mirror again. "Do you think boys will like me?"
Well. Not to go off on a feminist rant, but this is pretty thin
characterization for a girl. If we're talking like she has the personality
of *the girl who drowned there*, you might want to make that girl a
little more individual, instead of a collection of stereotypes.
You catch on quickly. Ranko is *meant* to come off like a collection
of stereotypes at first...
Rant aside -- I really like the idea of this
'fic, and you've done
some terrific things with it. The personality-thing has been used before,
but never quite like this, and never showing the viewpoint of the
*other* (that I know of). It's interesting how making the henshin
a separate personality seems to have moved Ranma and Akane's relationship
a bit farther than it is in the "real" story. I also like how you use
each "girl-change" (though I should hope you'd diverge from the manga
eventually; there's a lot of potential for fun here...)
Well, if you've seen a lot of the manga, you'll notice that quite
a number of things changed in China, and yes things will tend to diverge
more as time goes on.
Looking forward to the next part...
Thanks!
SKJAM!