After Ifurita "pointed" out that he missed my first set of reiews, I
noticed that I had received responses for reviews #1&2 but none for #1.
So, here is a repost of my first attempt at C&C.
Hello all!
Well, I'm back from my journey into the real world the past couple of
weeks and am digging out from under my pile of e-mail. As I'm going
through the fics, I thought "Hey, do a quick C&C as I read these!"
My rating system is based on 'Tea Kettles'
One = Read the intro, a couple more lines and went to the next fic.
Two = Read the fic, looked for the next fic.
Three = Read the fic, liked it. Good Fic.
Four = Great Fic!! Must Read!
Five = If you haven't read this, DO SO NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Awsome Fic.
Remember: THIS IS AN ENJOYMENT SCALE!!!
The more fun I had reading the fic, the greater the number of Tea
Kettles.
I'm just assuming that Five Kettles will be a rarity. ;)
And awaaay we go!
Ranma: [Notes] "Under the Hammer"
"Henry J. Cobb" <hcobb@io.com>
Quick Quote: "She drives like a madwoman, throws herself at Ranma and
eats her own cooking."
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: "Under the Hammer", Chapter three
"Henry J. Cobb" <hcobb@io.com>
Quick Quote: "One warning, she's totally nuts now. She tries to cook me
up for Christmas dinner, every year."
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: Regrets after it's too late (it's short, very short)
Neil Reynolds <neil@panix.com>
Too short
Two Tea Kettles
Ranma: The Missing Ingredient - Thy Inward Love : Aftermath
Richard Lawson <sterman@sprynet.com>
Quick Quote: "Kasumi. She was going a bit too far with this mothering
kick of hers. She needed to get pregnant very quickly, or Ukyo was
going to kill her."
Personaly, I liked it with Zen in it.
Four Tea Kettles
Ranma: Nullifier 122 - Part One (Half and Half : Ranma times two!)
Ranma: Nullifier 122 - Part Two
Ranma: x2 - Part One
Ranam: x2 - Part Two
WebDragon <kmark@odyssey.on.ca>
Same story, different titles/subjects
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: Operation: Unlikely (Part 1)
Ranma: Operation: Unlikely (Part 2)
MILL0622@Badger.Snow.edu (reposted by Travis Butler)
and then ....
Ranma: Operation: Unlikely (part 3A)
ERIN MILLS <emills@weber.edu>
Quick Quote: Ranma turned to look at her. "The Black Rose's real name is
Kodachi...Kodachi KUNO."
Two Tea Kettles
Ranma: Bubble, Bubble, Toil and Trouble [First Draft]
"G.L. Sandborn" <sandborn@microlink.net>
Quick Quote: "Feed!" she ordered, pointing to Elvis.
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: [Outline} Wild Highlander
Jack Ji <jackji@efn.org>
Quick Quote: "Akane: Ranma! No! (Runs over to Ranma's body and cries.)"
Waaay too short
Two Tea Kettles (Could be three if it was longer)
Ranma: Who's on first?
MUZZATTI LUCAS <e0fq7z7a@credit.erin.utoronto.ca>
Uhm, o.k.
One Tea Kettle
Ranma: The Caller's Plight (TCP) (all chapters)
Jorge Pratt <al709382@campus.ccm.itesm.mx>
Two Tea Kettles
Ranma: Flambe! Week 1/4 (Black-Bottomed Banana Bread)
bridget ellen engman <b-engma@students.uiuc.edu>
Quick Quote: <Some constructive criticism!> she grumped. <Collapsing on
the floor and writhing in agony isn't what I call constructive.
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: Lost Love. Part 1 of 2
Ranchan <ranchan@mail.accent.net>
Finish Part Two !
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: WORSE Chapter One
Scott Jamison <majks@cyberx.com>
Quick Quote: "One more thing before you go. Let me show you a quaint
Japanese custom. We call it 'using the door.'"
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: WORSE Chapter Two
Scott Jamison <majks@cyberx.com>
Must not have recieved a copy. :(
ZERO Tea Kettles
Ranma: WORSE Chapter Three
Scott Jamison <majks@cyberx.com>
Quick Quote: She had had it bad for Ryouga. At least until Friday.
Three Tea Kettles
GUNBUSTER: Catharsis - Prologue
GUNBUSTER: Catharsis
PHPN65A@prodigy.com (MR WILLIAM R GEIGER)
One Tea Kettle
Ranma: Romancing of the Two Tendou's (Ranma, #2)
"Michael Chen" <michael.h.chen@yale.edu>
Two Tea Kettles
Ranma: Herbal Remedy (Ranma, #3)
"Michael Chen" <michael.h.chen@yale.edu>
Two Tea Kettles
Ranma: Chasing the Wind Part 6
"J. Austin Wilde" <jaustin@aloha.net>
I am HOOKED! Arrgghh!
Five Tea Kettles
Ranma: Shizuku
Ranma: Shizuku: Epilogue (parody)
bridget ellen engman <b-engma@students.uiuc.edu>
Quick Quote: Ranma leapt after her, laughing. "You cannot escape!
Vengeance is mine!"
Four Tea Kettles
APCCGNN: Like Fish to a Cat
Richard Lawson <sterman@sprynet.com>
Quick Quote: "High so high. Nuku Nuku very high."
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: Natsumi 4 Update
Richard Beaubien <BEAUBIENRD@mala.bc.ca>
Two Tea Kettles
BGC: Die Hard 2032
"Todd Hill" <sysop@newberry.edu>
One Tea Kettle
AMG/OMG-Ranma: Aa! Megami-sensei! #13
"Bernard L. Ward" <eagleman@best.com>
Quick Quote: "I don't like how Urd's been trying to match me and Ucchan
up lately, but this isn't right at all.
Two Tea Kettles
Ranma: Ranma Z Part 1
Ranma: Ranma Z Part 2
"Ewen Cluney" <ryoga_hibiki@hotmail.com>
Two Tea Kettles
Ranma: Ranma Z Part 3
"Ewen Cluney" <ryoga_hibiki@hotmail.com>
It started to grow on me. :)
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: Fall of the Eagle Part 8
Stoner <stoner@elycion.geology.ualberta.ca>
Been a while, man.
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: Dark Empire part 6
Ifurita <walker@mail.accent.net>
Quick Quote: "Look at that!" Said Ranma
Your not supposed to point!
Three Tea Kettles
Ranma: Goodbye Ranma! part 1
Ranma: Goodbye Ranma! part 2
Ranma: Goodbye Ranma! part 3
Ranma: Goodbye Ranma! conclusion
"Zenki" <michael.h.chen@yale.edu>
Could be better
Three and a half Tea Kettles
Ranma: Happi-ness: Sunrise Chronicles pt. 2
Nightelf <nwl9354@tam2000.tamu.edu>
Quick Quote: "Lesson number zero: Never, _ever_ challenge me for my
hand in marriage."
Four Tea Kettles
*YAWWWWWWN*
I'm getting tired. Reviewed Fanfics were posted from 10-1 to 10-7.
That's all for now, until next time: "And I'm BUILT better, to boot!"