Subject: Re: [FanFic] Mechwarrior Team Jusenkyo Chapter 1
From: "Mike W. Loader" <mloader@scs.unr.edu>
Date: 4/6/1996, 3:18 AM
To: fanfic@tendo-dojo.ranma.net
CC: fanfic@tendo-dojo.ranma.net

   Hmm...interesting idea. Speaking as an old Banshee driver, I found the 
way you integrated the two appealing. The writing had a crisp style to it 
that captures the spirit of the game.
   BUT....being a nitpicker at heart, I've decided to point out stuff 
that only another Battletech junkie would notice.

1.>      Pushing hard on the controls, the Lost Boy brought his mech's arm 
back for a punch.  <It won't do a tenth of a PPC's damage, but 45 tons of 
wrecking ball punches will flatten that bastard!> he thought, slamming 
the controls forward. 

A punch from a 85-ton Battlemaster would do 9 points of damage, just 
below a PPC's 10 points. In addition, Ryoga's chance of hitting Ranma's 
'mech in the cockpit and killing him are about 1 in 6.

2.       > Both pilots were about to reply when another new voice 
entered.  "No worry, Phoenix.  I take care Locusts.

   Given the Clans attitude on respect for Star League language, I find 
it puzzling that Shampoo is talking like this. Clansmen get upset at the 
use of _contractions_, for crying out loud. A bit out of place, quiaff?

3.      >  The man fumed for a second, but he was thirsty, so he let the 
insult slide.  "Very well then, 'Cologne,'" he said.  "I am Galaxy 
Commander Herb, formerly of Clan Wolf."

   Clan Wolf, a Warden clan with greater respect (well, tolerance anyway) 
of Freebirths than any other clan save Diamond Shark, is a curious choice 
to have Herb belong to. Smoke Jaguar or Jade Falcon would match his 
attitude more fittingly.

4.      >  "The movement was a disaster, the clans tore my unit apart and 
forced us to retreat."  As he said it, Akane saw the look in his eyes 
that said he remembered the mission like it had just happened.  "I was 
covering the rear of the retreat in my Behemoth ,my legs got shot out 
>from under me and the mech went down.  I guess I blacked out for a 
minute, because the next thing I knew,

   The 100-ton Behemoth battlemech, designed by Stefan Amaris for the 
defence of Terra against General Kerensky and the SLDF, was deemed a 
failure due to trouble with the leg actuators. Although the Clans later 
on solved this problem after the Exodus, there have been no Behemoths in 
the Inner Sphere since before the First Successor War, making it 
impossible for Jase to have piloted one against the clans.

   Gomen about the nitpicking. Cool story, can't wait for part two.

-Mike of No Particular Title or Handle

       ^
      / \
     /   \
    /     \
   /  (O)  \          THIS IS A PUBLIC SERVICE MESSAGE FROM MIKE LOADER,
  /         \         THE LV ILUMINATUS, AMALGAMATED CONSOLIDATED, INC.,
 /           \        AND 23 OTHER FINE, FINE CITIZENS. PLEASE STAY WHERE YOU
/             \       ARE.HAIL ERIS - ALL HAIL DISCORDIA. FNORD.
---------------                       mloader@scs.unr.edu