This guy ticks me off.  No, I mean it.  Who the hell does he think he
is?

He appears to be someone who actualy read _each_ of the Ranma FFs on
r.a.a.s, and kept some notes on each story, so as to review them.

You bet. Not only did he or she cover a lot of fanfics, giving me a 
couple of interesting leads, he actually _gave supporting details_. There 
was more thought in that post than in some fanfics.