Subject: Re: Ranma & Nabiki 4 pre-release.
From: Mike A Lyons
Date: 11/4/1995, 9:46 PM
To: fanfic@andrew.cais.com

On Sat, 4 Nov 1995, Mr. the Rutsch wrote:

"I act like myself!  If he doesn't like me for who I am, why am I
getting married to him?"  As soon as she said it, Nabiki wished she
could take it back.  She blushed, realizing what a lame **change
"lame"** comment she had made.

Hmm.  How about "thoughtless?"

"Hey Ranma!  If you're going to take a bath, can you wash up P-Chan
for me?"  Ranma-chan agreed by way of taking the pig in hand and
walking into the bath.  It seemed stupid to him.  Akane hadn't bought
the pig or even made an effort to find the real owner.  She should
have at least called the pound.  Or did the pound not deal with pigs?

When did Ryouga find out about Ranma's curse?  Or does he just not care
much one way or another?

- Did the dinner scene seem to progress too rapidly?  Did what Nabiki did 
make sense to y'all?

No, the dinner scene was fine.  Sneaking out without paying seems like a 
little too much, though.. wouldn't that offend Nabiki's entrepreneurial 
spirit?

-Heretical non-Hentai story question: Should Ranma and Nabiki have sex in 
the final scene of the story?  

Definitely not, for the reason you mention: it would taint what has so far
been a refreshingly faithful (though different!) rendition of the
Ranmaverse.  There are, after all, a lot of dark and depressing Ranma 
fanfics floating around the 'net these days.  ;-)

(Before I'm lynched by 50% of the fanfic authors here: not that there's
anything wrong with the "dark" stuff!  It's just nice to see a "normal"
story once in a while.)

I think it might be interesting to reconcile what they did for the next 
few episodes.  

It might, but it belongs in a new fanfic (perhaps even a short side
story?).  R&N has too much potential, and you've put too much work into it
already, to go and reduce it to that level (all IMHO). 

(Before I'm lynched by RR: not that there's... ;-)

-The ukulele scene: I didn't make the fanfic a "how to play ukulele" 
instructional, did I?  Teaching the basics of an instrument is very sweet 
in real life but I don't know how well it translated. 

Naw, it was fine (although it's hard to picture Ranma playing the
ukulele!). 


Interesting story.  Keep 'em coming!