Subject: Re: [FFML] [Fanfic][Ranma] Burns Brightest
From: "Mr. the Rutsch" <jdrutsch@ucdavis.edu>
Date: 7/10/1996, 7:55 PM
To: fanfic@fanfic.com

On Wed, 10 Jul 1996 gaffney@iconn.net wrote:

Seriously, you seemed to have misnamed the character of Ryouga
in your fanfic, who bears no resemblance to Ryouga in any Ranma
story by Miss Takahashi.

I dunnow...he invoked Mr. Hayashi's "how to fanfic" escape clause by 
setting things a few years in the future ^_^.

Ms. Takahashi makes Ryouga petty, irresponsible, and spiteful.  He's 
tried to kill Ranma innumerable times, and he initially tried to kill 
Ukyou just for being Ranma's friend.  Mr. Crewson makes Ryouga petty, 
irresponsible, and spiteful.  He's tried to kill a number of girls (or at 
least give them AIDS), and he almost kills Miyuki for giving him AIDS.  

The darkness and the differences from RT's Ranma didn't come from poor 
characterization, it came from taking things seriously.  Perhaps treating 
the violence as real, rather than cartoonish, is non-canon...but it's 
not bad, it's just another perspective.  

If Ryouga was to get AIDS, the story seems realistic enough.  Certainly 
interesting.  I mean, Ryouga is shown (by RT) to have homicidal 
tendencies, and he'd take out his anger on someone...my gripe is that 
Ryouga seems too base to do something as subtle as sleep with girls 
after breaking the condom...

Not one to review.

I disagree, as with most of the "Classic Reviews" choices, but 
unfortunately other people have different opinions than me ^_^.

Jeff

****jdrutsch@ucdavis.edu***********************Jeff Rutsch***************** 
I -I -I-I *"She's a kind hearted woman, she studies evil all the time.
IV-IV-I-I * She's a kind hearted woman, she studies evil all the time.
V -IV-I-I * You well's to kill me, as to have it on your mind."-R. Johnson
**^_^***.daed si luaP**^_^**Bird Lives**^_^**Ranma Loves Akane**^_^****^_^*